An exclusive school system won’t build an inclusive society

by Richard Denniss in The Canberra Times

Share

Originally published in The Canberra Times on January 14, 2012

Should wealthy art collectors have to contribute to the cost of public galleries if they choose not to visit them, or should their contribution be refunded to help them extend their own collection? Should city residents have to contribute to the cost of upgrading regional hospitals they will never use, or should their contribution be refunded to help them pay for their own private health care? Should parents of private school children have to contribute to the cost of public schools they choose not to enrol their children in or should their contribution be refunded to help them meet the rapidly rising cost of private school tuition? The great thing about democracy is that there is no right answer to those three questions, nor is there any need to answer them consistently. No doubt some wealthy rural families feel differently about the obligation of the public at large to fund regional roads and hospitals than they do about their obligation to fund public schools they would never send their kids to. But perhaps the worst thing about democracy is the tendency for people to dress self-interest up as principle and the growing unwillingness of the media and our politicians to call it what it is.

Related documents

Attachment

Between the Lines Newsletter

The biggest stories and the best analysis from the team at the Australia Institute, delivered to your inbox every fortnight.

You might also like

Private schools, public subsidies: with $50k fees per child per year, how can tax breaks be justified?

Private schools are competing to see who can boast the most luxurious accoutrements, and the tax-deductions they can claim on constructing buildings are helping them do it. The Scots College is awaiting construction of its new library, which will resemble a Scottish Baronial castle. At one point, they had a hypoxic chamber for altitude simulation sports training. Newington College