Economics and politics don’t really have much in common. While it is the job of politicians to decide what is fair and what is not, students are taught in economics 101 that economics is not concerned with fairness and distribution. The main job of economists is to help grow the pie, and the main job of politicians is to share it out. Last week’s review of the Renewable Energy Target (RET) chaired by Dick Warburton provides a textbook example of just how incompatible economic and political logic can be.
Dick Warburton is proud to call himself a climate sceptic. And like many people with no expertise in the energy market, his starting point was the assumption that the RET was a source of upward pressure on electricity prices. Unfortunately for Mr Warburton however, the modelling conducted for his inquiry soon showed that the opposite was the case. Indeed, Mr Warburton spent hundreds of thousands of taxpayers’ dollars on modelling by ACIL Tasman that confirmed the conclusion of four other modelling exercises.
Related documents
Between the Lines Newsletter
The biggest stories and the best analysis from the team at the Australia Institute, delivered to your inbox every fortnight.
You might also like
The Climate Crisis is an Integrity Crisis | Polly Hemming
I am starting my address to this year’s summit in the exact same way that I started last year’s address. Because it is just over a year since I delivered these same words, which aren’t actually my words. They are the words of our Climate Change Minister, and they provide a baseline of sorts for what progress has been made in that time.
Profit-Price Spiral an Inconvenient Truth for Big Business: Economists
Despite a mainstream shift in the national conversation away from baseless claims of a “wage-price spiral”, some big business proponents and conservative economists appear unwilling to accept the economic evidence of a profit-price spiral.
Labor’s pledge to depoliticise the public service is undermined by the government only hearing what it wants to hear on climate change
While last year’s robodebt royal commission exposed a shocking lack of ethics among senior ranks of the Australian public service, the systemic condition still largely seems to be regarded as an aberration.