Never mind Liberal v Labor – right now, it’s Big Gas v the rest

Australia is one of the world’s largest gas exporters. We send around 80% of our gas overseas. More than half of the gas we export doesn’t even earn royalties or resources rent tax. We are literally giving away our gas resources.
None of that has stopped the gas industry from trying to convince us for the past few years that a gas shortage is imminent. Instead of taking responsibility for the problem they are causing for they’ve relentlessly attacked the Victorian Labor Government, characterizing the banning of gas connections to new homes they see as “the demonisation of gas”, when in fact the government’s attempt to reduce the state’s dependence on gas is exactly the right response to gas industry engineered scarcity and price gouging.
All of the major political candidates at this election have acknowledged that there’s “no gas supply shortage in Australia”. Labor’s energy minister Chris Bowen, who admitted at the National Press Club yesterday that “a lot gets exported”, was the last to arrive at the party.
Gas producers and their industry associations try to get their voices heard in multiple ways. One approach is to contribute to major parties’ finances. In 2023-24, Australian Energy Producers disclosed almost $95,000 in contributions to the Labor Party, and a further $77,000 to the Coalition.
Hedging is a good investment approach but hasn’t worked as a political strategy, which is why they’ve resorted to outright criticism of the Coalition over its proposed gas reservation plan. AEP boss Samantha McCulloch says it would be “another heavy-handed intervention” that leaves gas companies “no incentive” for boosting domestic supply.
Asked about the gas industry’s criticism of his new gas reservation policy on Wednesday, Peter Dutton bluntly retorted: “Are we here to line the pockets of the gas companies? No.”
AEP has also been conducting polling in support of gas to apply pressure on independent MPs in Kooyong and Goldstein. To be fair, neither Monique Ryan nor Zoe Daniel are likely to lose sleep over this.
It’s not just the political parties who are hardening up in the face of the gas industry propaganda.
Every year, the Australian Energy Market Operator comes out with a Gas Statement of Opportunities. That document forecasts gas usage in the coming years, and although it consistently shows declining demand for gas, it also warns of potential peak-day shortfalls in the southeast. It is usually followed by plenty of scaremongering about a “looming gas crisis”.
This year, the report itself was subdued and the media coverage less gullible. The Sydney Morning Herald said that gas substitution policies were making a difference, and even the AFR conceded that the prospect of a “gas crisis” had “slightly eased” in the short term.
Many Australians seem to be turning on gas (figuratively speaking). It’s one of the only interesting things about this election so far.
Between the Lines Newsletter
The biggest stories and the best analysis from the team at the Australia Institute, delivered to your inbox every fortnight.
You might also like
6 gas facts to help you cut through fossil fuel spin
There’s a lot of misinformation in the debate surrounding Australia’s gas industry. To be clear: the world cannot afford for new gas projects (or any other fossil fuel projects) to be opened if we want to avoid dangerous climate change.
Budgets are about choices | Between the Lines
This edition: government locks in fossil fuel expansion, an honest government ad and our budget preview
As Pacific Islands Forum meets, the government should admit we do not need more gas
Claims that LNG gas can’t be used to meet any shortages in south-east Australia are completely false given how much uncontracted LNG capacity Australia has over the next 20 years.