Spreading the benefits of the boom only so far
Budget speeches are always carefully scripted to try and influence how the media frames its coverage. This year the main message the government wanted conveyed was that it is spreading the benefits of the mining boom.
But as is so often the case, the budget papers belie the priorities outlined in the Treasurer’s speech. Beyond the feel-good sound bite, how accurate is it to describe the budget as spreading the benefits of the boom?
Despite record profits – $51 billion in 2009/10 – the mining industry receives substantial assistance from Australian taxpayers worth more than $4 billion per year. The biggest concession is in the form of the Fuel Tax Credit Scheme which sees the mining industry pay no tax on diesel used for transport. In the lead-up to the budget there had been intense speculation that this subsidy would be removed, saving the government around $2 billion per year. This was not borne out in the budget papers, the government left it untouched. In fact, all $4 billion in subsidies to the mining industry were left untouched. Worse still, the budget papers show that the government has downgraded the revenue it expects to receive from the Minerals Resource Rent Tax by 20 per cent.
So while the Treasurer’s speech referred heavily to spreading the benefits of the boom, there is very little evidence to suggest that will be the case. Here’s a few other ways the $4 billion in subsidies that go to the mining industry each year could have been spent:
- Increasing Newstart Allowance by $50/week = $1.2 billion per year
- Denticare = $1.3 billion per year
- Gonski education reforms = $1.5 billion per year.
Between the Lines Newsletter
The biggest stories and the best analysis from the team at the Australia Institute, delivered to your inbox every fortnight.
You might also like
McCarthy’s fall and the far-right influence on American foreign policy
Critical support for Ukraine’s war effort could be torpedoed by a small minority of US congressional extremists.
Inequality on Steroids | Between the Lines
The Wrap with Richard Denniss While everyone knows inequality has been rising in Australia, our recent report ‘Inequality on Steroids’ revealed some alarming figures that shocked even me: since 2009, 93% of our economic growth has flowed to the top 10% of income earners. I was always suspicious about claims the benefits of economic growth
The Intergenerational Report notes that productivity matters, but we also need to care as much about who benefits
The forecast of productivity growth in the Intergenerational Report is not all doom and gloom – but it will be if workers continue to receive less than their fair share of the benefits