Victoria’s brown coal power plants undermining reliability of national grid


Over summer there were 16 major breakdowns at Victoria’s three brown coal plants, Loy Yang A, Loy Yang B and Yallourn. All of these breakdowns saw hundreds of megawatts of capacity withdrawn from the grid almost instantly. This made Victoria the standout state for power plant breakdowns.

breakdowns per station

Between the 15th and 21st of January, at the height of summer, there were six breakdowns, an average of one every day.

Even more alarming were two fires. The first was at Loy Yang A on January 6th, within 500m of the mine. The other was in the actual coal pit of Yallourn on February 4th, the anniversary of the Hazelwood fires that burned for 45 days, cost $100 million dollars and endangered the health of 14,000 Morwell residents.

These breakdowns caused blowouts in electricity prices. The Loy Yang B breakdown on January 18th at the height of heatwave peak demand caused wholesale prices to rise to $13000 MWh, estimated to have cost $168 million. 

vic coal fail 2

vic coal fail 3

“Victoria’s brown coal power plants are a huge liability for the National Electricity Market.” Say Ben Oquist, Executive Director of The Australia Institute.

“It is a credit to the workers of these plants that they keep them running as well as they do. However they are now too old, too unreliable, too polluting and too dangerous. It’s time to replace them with up-to-date technology.”

“They may be cheap for the companies to operate, but when they break down in the middle of summer and cause electricity prices to skyrocket, we all end up paying.”

“They perform particularly badly on hot days. In an era of increasing heatwaves, more break downs are inevitable.”

“The Hazelwood fire showed us the devastating costs of fires in brown coal mines. The two fire incidents this year show that the risk of more fires is high and one we shouldn’t be taking.”

Vorath (2018) Frydenberg slapped down on Twitter after ignoring coal failure,

Related research

General Enquiries

Emily Bird Office Manager

02 6130 0530

Media Enquiries

David Barnott-Clement Media Advisor

0457 974 636

RSS Feed

Media Releases