…. while they inflate the amount of tax they pay.
Firms are keen on self regulation. They claim it works because they are transparent, accountable and good corporate citizens. In March, Rio Tinto released a voluntary report called Taxes paid in 2011, which showed the amount of tax that Rio Tinto paid worldwide. Rio was upfront in its press release on why it had produced the report:
This report demonstrates that effective disclosures can be made by businesses on a voluntary basis, in a similar fashion to what has been achieved in the area of sustainable development reporting, and that there is no need for additional legislation.
The report showed in a Table called “Our tax payments in 2011” that it paid in total $6.7 billion in tax to Australian Federal and State Governments. But how good was the report in demonstrating “that effective disclosures can be made by business on a voluntary basis”?
Well, based on that Table you might mistakenly believe that $6.7 billion was how much Rio Tinto paid in tax. But you would be wrong. The figure actually includes both taxes that Rio had to pay and taxes collected by Rio. Taxes collected included $880 million in PAYE tax.
That is, Rio included the taxes paid by its employees. That’s a pretty nifty way to inflate the company’s figures.
The $6.7 billion also included just over $2 billion in royalties. Royalties are not taxes but rather payment to the owners of the minerals (i.e. the government on behalf of us) for the minerals that Rio Tinto has extracted. Counting royalties as taxes is a bit like counting postage costs to Australia Post as taxes.
If we take out the taxes paid by employees and the royalty payments, the $6.7 billion Rio Tinto claims slumps to $3.75 billion. If this is Rio Tinto’s attempts to convince us that further legislation is not needed in sustainable development reporting then we’re unconvinced. In describing its report Rio Tinto goes on to say:
In a number of areas, including sustainable development reporting, voluntary transparency has been shown to encourage innovation in reporting.
Innovative reporting indeed.
Between the Lines Newsletter
The biggest stories and the best analysis from the team at the Australia Institute, delivered to your inbox every fortnight.
You might also like
What is the PRRT?
Gas extraction is often lauded by the industry as the ‘backbone of the Australian economy’, but the actual revenue collected from one of the main taxes on the industry falls staggeringly short of what most people would expect. Find out why this is the case – and what we can do to fix it.
Australia’s Great Gas Giveaway | Between the Lines
This edition: Independents call out the gas industry and Australia’s consultant addiction continues
Big profits, but don’t be suckered into thinking mining dominates Australia’s economy
Mining companies love to talk about how much they contribute to Australia’s economy. But really their biggest “contribution” is their profits – and they want to keep more of those.